Skip links
short-term disability

Navigating Short-Term Disability Denials: Insights and Solutions 2024.


In the crucible of an unexpected illness or injury, Short-Term Disability insurance can be a beacon of hope. The safety net assures us that if we fall, we won’t hit the ground with the full force of financial instability. However, the comfort of protection often feels elusive when a claim is unexpectedly denied. 

Table of Contents

For many, a denial can seem arbitrary or unjust, leaving individuals and their families scrambling to understand why their insurance, which they’ve contributed to for years, is not coming through in their time of need. 

This blog post is a detailed road map through the murky waters of short-term disability denials. It provides insights into why they happen and offers practical solutions to combat them.

Short-term disability denials can be a frustrating and confusing experience, but understanding the reasons behind them can help individuals take proactive steps to prevent or overcome them. 

One of the common reasons for denials is that more medical documentation needs to be completed. Insurance companies require extensive documentation to support claims. If any information needs to be included or is deemed adequate, it can result in a denial.
Additionally, pre-existing conditions and the specifics of an individual’s policy coverage can also play a role in denials. Many policies have specific exclusions for pre-existing conditions, meaning that if an individual has a condition they were treated for before obtaining the insurance, their claim may be denied. 

It is important to thoroughly review policy coverage before claiming to avoid surprises.
Another factor that can contribute to denials is the length of the disability. Insurance companies may deny claims if they believe an individual will be able to return to work within a short period, even if they are currently unable to do so. 

This can be especially frustrating for individuals who have ongoing medical conditions or disabilities that require intermittent leave from work.

insurance, family, few-454895.jpg

Understanding Short-Term Disability Insurance

Before delving into the complexities of denials, it’s essential to have a thorough understanding of Short-Term Disability  insurance. This type of coverage provides income replacement for individuals who are temporarily unable to work due to illness, injury, or childbirth. 

It typically pays out a percentage of the person’s salary for a specified period, usually up to 26 weeks. Employers may offer short-term disability insurance as part of their benefits package, or individuals can purchase it independently.

Short-term disability insurance is designed to provide financial stability during a temporary inability to work, allowing individuals to focus on recovering without the added stress of financial strain. However, certain limitations and requirements must be met for a successful claim. These include:

  • There is a waiting period before benefits kick in, usually between 0 and 14 days.
  • A minimum number of hours worked or contributions made to the insurance plan.
  • A specified definition of disability varies, but generally means that the individual cannot perform their job duties due to illness or injury. 

It’s important to note that short-term disability insurance is not the same as workers’ compensation, which covers work-related injuries or illnesses. It also differs from long-term disability insurance, which covers extended absences of six months or longer.

Common Reasons for Short-Term Disability Denials

Despite being intended as a safety net, short-term disability claims are often denied for various reasons. Some of the most common include:

  • Insufficient medical documentation: Insurance companies require detailed and specific medical records to support a disability claim. Claims may be denied if they are provided or meet certain criteria allowed.
  • Failure to meet eligibility requirements: Certain conditions must be met for a successful claim, such as a waiting period or minimum hours worked. If an individual meets these requirements, their claim may be allowed.
  • Discrepancies in information: In some cases, there may be discrepancies between the information provided by the individual, their employer, and their medical providers. This can lead to confusion and ultimately result in a denial.
  • Pre-existing conditions: Some insurance policies may exclude coverage for pre-existing conditions, meaning that any disability related to a previous medical issue will not be covered.
  • Lack of cooperation: Insurance companies may require individuals to undergo certain medical exams or provide additional information. Failure to cooperate with these requests can lead to a denial.
wheelchair, care, disabled-908343.jpg

Reasons for Short-Term Disability Denials

Despite seemingly meeting all the requirements, short-term disability claims can still be denied. Some of the most common reasons for denials include:

  • Insufficient medical evidence: Claims must be supported by medical documentation that proves an individual’s illness or injury is severe enough to prevent them from working.
  • Pre-existing conditions: Insurance companies may deny claims if they determine that an illness or injury was pre-existing before the individual’s enrollment in the insurance plan.
  • Failure to meet the waiting period: If an individual submits a claim before the specified period, it can result in a denial.
  • Inaccurate or incomplete information: Any discrepancies or missing information on a claim can result in denial.
  • Failure to meet the definition of disability: As mentioned before, each insurance policy has its own definition of disability, and if an individual’s condition doesn’t match, their claim may be denied.
medical, appointment, doctor-563427.jpg

Discrepancies in Medical Records

One of the most frustrating reasons for claim denials is discrepancies in medical records that raise red flags for the insurance company.

The Case of the Missing Information

Sometimes, critical details can be overlooked or omitted, which can harm the credibility of your claim. It’s your responsibility to ensure that all information provided to the insurance company is accurate and complete.

When Doctor A Doesn’t Agree with Doctor B

When multiple healthcare providers are involved, it’s not uncommon for conflict reports. This inconsistency can be a red flag for insurers. Ensuring all your doctors are on the same page can alleviate this concern.

Non-Compliance with Treatment Plans

Your claim may be denied if your medical records show non-compliance with prescribed treatment.

The Art of Following Doctor’s Orders

If you disagree with your treatment plan, discussing this with your doctor is important. Non-compliance can significantly weaken your claim.

The Stubborn Patient: Why Non-Compliance Is a No-No

While it’s your right to make informed decisions about your healthcare, insurance companies see non-compliance as a lack of effort to recover and return to work.

Inaccurate or Incomplete Application

Sometimes, the issue isn’t with the evidence but the application itself. Only complete or accurate information can lead to processing delays or flat-out denial.

Truth or Dare: The Application Edition

When filling out your application, be as truthful and thorough as possible. Any discrepancies can call your claim into question.

Failure to Cooperate with the Insurance Company

Once your claim is submitted, you may be asked to provide additional information or undergo an independent medical examination (IME). Failing to cooperate can result in a denial.

The Waiting Room Blues: The Importance of Communication

If you need help information promptly, communicate this to the insurance company. Establishing open lines of communication can temper their expectations and prevent unnecessary denial.

The Dilemma of Independent Medical Examinations

An IME is when an insurance company requires you to be examined by a doctor. If you refuse or don’t attend, your claim may be denied.

Coverage Limitations and Exclusions

Understanding the limitations and exclusions of your policy is critical. Many policies do not cover certain conditions or circumstances.

Reading Between the Lines: Understanding Policy Terms

Don’t just read your policy —study it. Understand what is covered and what isn’t. If there’s anything you’re unsure about, ask for clarification before it becomes an issue.

The Devil’s in the Details: Uncovering Exclusions

Policies often contain fine print that outlines exclusions. For example, some policies may not cover ‘self-inflicted’ injuries, which could be interpreted in ways that might surprise you. Make sure you understand the full scope of these exclusions.

Administrative Errors

Lastly, administrative errors can occur that lead to a denial. This could be anything from a lost form to a clerical mistake while processing your claim.

Lost in Translation: The Perils of Processing Mistakes

To avoid this, keep a meticulous record of all correspondence with the insurance company. Follow up on every submitted form and request to ensure it was received and processed.

The Paper Trail: Avoiding Mishaps

Create a paper trail for every step of your claim process. This can be invaluable if you need to dispute a denial.

Lack of Occupational Disability

One of the more complex reasons for denial is that your disability doesn’t align with your occupation’s requirements or criteria.

Clocking In: When Disability Doesn’t Align with Occupation

Be prepared to demonstrate how your disability prevents you from performing the duties of your specific job. This can require a detailed understanding of your daily work activities and the functional tasks that are critical to your role.

The Gray Area of Work Limitations

It’s not always black and white. Sometimes, a disability may limit your ability to perform certain tasks, but not all of them. In this case, it’s about proving the impact on your ability to work overall.

couple, elderly, retirement-7793079.jpg

Fighting Short-Term Disability Denials

Receiving a denial notice can be devastating, but it’s important not to lose hope. There are steps individuals can take to fight a denial, including:

  • Requesting an appeal: Most insurance companies have an appeals process that allows individuals to provide more information or evidence to support their claim.
  • Gathering additional evidence: If the insurance company cited insufficient medical evidence as the reason for denial, gathering more documentation from healthcare providers may be beneficial.
  • Seeking legal assistance: If the appeals process is unsuccessful, individuals may consider seeking legal assistance to review their case and file a lawsuit against the insurance company.
man on a wheelchair, wheelchair, push-5073595.jpg

The Unfortunate Reality: Denials Happen

Despite the assurance that insurance companies exist to protect their policyholders, denials are more common than one might think. Understanding the root causes of these denials can better equip you to proactively build a case that holds up under scrutiny.

Insufficient Medical Evidence

One of the most common reasons for denial is the absence of compelling medical documentation. Insurance companies require clear evidence that an individual’s medical condition is severe enough to prevent them from working. This could include doctor’s notes, test results, and a documented treatment history.

The Importance of Strong Documentation

The key to overcoming this hurdle is diligence. Keep detailed records of all interactions with healthcare professionals, and ensure that your medical records accurately reflect the severity of your condition.

When the Doctor Doesn’t Have Your Back

Feel free to advocate for yourself if your doctor seems reticent to provide the necessary documentation. Explain the importance of the paperwork and its impact on your financial well-being. Sometimes, a second opinion can also provide the validation you need.

wheelchair, disability, paraplegic-1595794.jpg

Setting the Stage: Understanding Short-Term Disability

To appreciate the intricacies of claim denials, we first need a solid grounding in what short-term disability is and how it’s designed to work. Short-term disability insurance is typically provided by an employer or can be purchased independently and kicks in when an employee cannot work due to illness or injury. The length of coverage varies but generally spans from a few weeks to several months.

Understanding your policy’s terms and conditions is the first step in knowing what to expect. Policies may differ in eligibility criteria, the amount paid, the length of the benefit period, and the definition of “disability.” Failing to familiarize yourself with these critical details can lead to unpleasant surprises.

The Quest for Objective Proof

Insurance companies often look for objective evidence of a disability. This can be challenging, especially if your condition is not easily quantifiable through tests or imaging. Providing as much context and detail as possible can help bridge this gap.

Pre-existing Conditions

Another common cause for denials is the presence of pre-existing conditions. This term is only sometimes straightforward and can vary between policies. Understanding how your policy defines a pre-existing condition is essential.

The Pre-existing Conundrum

For some, the denial may be due to a condition before the policy existed. In contrast, for others, it may be a condition for which treatment was sought in the months leading up to the claim. Either way, it’s crucial to report this history accurately and work within the timeframes provided in your policy.

Exceptions and Exclusions: Navigating Policy Terms

Policy terms often contain clauses that outline what does and does not qualify as a pre-existing condition. Review these carefully and ensure you understand how they apply to your situation.

Failure to Meet Eligibility Criteria

Even if you have a clear need for short-term disability, failing to meet the policy’s eligibility criteria can result in a denial.

cry, harm, accident pain-2764843.jpg

Solutions for Overcoming Short-Term Disability Denials

Receiving a short-term disability denial can be a devastating blow, but it’s important not to give up hope. There are steps that individuals can take to combat denials and potentially have their claims approved.

  • Appeal the decision: Many insurance companies have an appeals process for denied claims. This involves providing additional information or documentation to support the claim and presenting a strong case for approval.
  • Seek legal assistance: If the appeals process is unsuccessful, individuals may seek legal help. An experienced attorney can review the denial and provide guidance on the next steps, including potentially filing a lawsuit against the insurance company.
  • Look into alternative sources of income: In some cases, receiving other forms of financial assistance may be possible while waiting for a short-term disability claim to be approved. This could include government benefits, such as social security disability or unemployment insurance.


Weighing the Pros and Cons of Filing a Short-Term Disability Claim

Navigating the waters of short-term disability claims can be complex, but understanding the potential advantages and disadvantages is crucial for making an informed decision. Here are some key points to consider:


  1. Financial Support: One of the most immediate benefits of a successful short-term disability claim is financial support. This can provide a vital lifeline when you cannot work and earn a regular income.
  2. Recovery Time: With the financial pressures alleviated, you can focus on what’s most important – your health. This means taking the necessary time to recover fully without rushing back to work, which could compromise your long-term wellness.
  3. Job Security: Short-term disability claims often come with legal protections that ensure your job (or a similar position) is available once you’re ready to return, offering peace of mind during your recovery.


  1. Claim Denial Risks: As outlined in the previous sections, a claim might be denied for numerous reasons, ranging from pre-existing conditions to discrepancies in medical records. The process can be time-consuming and may only sometimes result in approval.
  2. Bureaucratic Challenges: The process of filing a claim can be daunting, involving a lot of paperwork, strict adherence to deadlines, and the potential need to contest a denial, which can add stress during an already challenging time.
  3. Possible Stigma: In some workplace cultures, a stigma might be associated with taking short-term disability leave, which could affect relationships with colleagues or perceptions of commitment to one’s job despite the claim’s legitimacy.



What happens if my short-term disability (STD) claim is denied?

If your STD claim is denied, you have the right to appeal the decision. This typically involves submitting additional documentation or clarifications regarding your condition and the reasons for your claim. It’s also advisable to consult with a legal professional who specializes in disability claims to guide you through the appeals process.

What is the most common reason for short-term disability in the U.S.?

Musculoskeletal disorders, including back pain and injuries, are the most common reasons for short-term disability claims in the United States.

What qualifies for short-term disability in Canada?

Qualifying conditions for short-term disability in Canada commonly include injuries, illnesses, or medical conditions that temporarily prevent an individual from working. Each policy has specific criteria, so reviewing your plan’s details is essential.

Can you be fired while on short-term disability in Ontario?

In Ontario, employees are typically protected from being fired due to illness or disability. However, if an employer can prove that the firing is unrelated to the disability or illness, it may be legally permissible.

Can you travel while on short-term disability in Canada?

While technically possible, it’s important to consult your policy and inform your insurance provider before travelling. Activities inconsistent with recovery reasons for the claim might impact your benefits.

Can you return to work after a short-term disability in Ontario?

Yes, you can return to work after a short-term disability leave in Ontario, often with recommendations from your most provider about any needed accommodations or adjustments to your work conditions.

What is the most approved disability?

Mental health disorders, particularly depression and anxiety, are among the most commonly approved conditions for disability benefits.

How long is the most short-term disability?

Short-term disability benefits typically last three to six months, varying depending on your policy and situation.

What is the most common reason for disability?

Musculoskeletal disorders and mental health issues are among the most common reasons for both short and long-term disabilities.

How many weeks is a short-term disability in Canada?

Short-term disability benefits in Canada can last from a few weeks up to six months, depending on the policy specifics and the individual’s condition.

What is the waiting period for short-term disability in Canada?

The waiting period for short-term disability benefits in Canada can range from a few days to several weeks after the onset of the disability or submission of the claim.

How do you get short-term disability approved for anxiety and depression in Canada?

To get short-term disability approved for anxiety and depression, a detailed medical report from your healthcare provider outlining how your condition impacts your ability to work is essential. Consistent and ongoing treatment documentation can support your claim.

What STD is not permanent?

STD refers to short-term disability, which, by definition, is not permanent. It’s designed to provide financial assistance during a temporary illness or injury.

Can an STD return?

Yes, if you recover from your disability and return to work but then experience a relapse or new episode related to or separate from the initial condition, you may re-qualify for STD benefits, depending on your policy’s terms.

Can you be fired while on short-term disability in Alberta?

Like Ontario, Alberta laws protect employees from being fired due to illness or disability. Still, employers may terminate employment for reasons unrelated to the employee’s health status.

Why is it so hard to get a disability application in the U.S.?

Getting disability benefits in the U.S. can be challenging due to stringent eligibility criteria, the need for comprehensive medical evidence, and the high volume of applications, leading to long processing times.

What is an elimination period?

The elimination period is between an illness or injury’s onset and when you start receiving disability benefits. It’s similar to a deductible period in insurance terms.

What is the most common disability in the U.S.?

Musculoskeletal disorders, particularly those affecting the back and spine, are the most common disabilities in the U.S.

Who is eligible for Canadian disability?

Eligibility for Canadian disability benefits depends on your specific disability insurance policy, CPP disability benefits, or other government programs – generally requiring sufficient proof of a significant and prolonged disability.

What disability benefits are available in Canada?

Canada offers several disability benefits, including the Canada Pension Plan Disability Benefits (CPP-D), provincial social assistance programs, and private insurance policies.

How long does Canada Life take to process a claim?

Processing times can vary, but Canada Life aims to process claims quickly. The exact time may depend on the claim’s complexity and the submitted documentation’s completeness.

Who is eligible for short-term disability in Ontario?

Eligibility for short-term disability in Ontario typically depends on your employer’s policy or if you have private disability insurance. Generally, you must be unable to work due to a medical condition.

Can I quit my job while on long-term disability in Canada?

Quitting your job while on long-term disability may affect your benefits, depending on your policy’s terms. It’s essential to consult your policy or a legal professional before making any decisions.

Is stress leave paid in Ontario?

Stress leave may be covered under short-term disability insurance if medically warranted, depending on your workplace’s policies or insurance coverage.

What is the most common cause of permanent and long-term disability?

Permanent and long-term disabilities are most commonly caused by chronic illnesses, severe musculoskeletal injuries, and mental health disorders.

What are the three most common disabilities in the United States?

Musculoskeletal disorders, cardiovascular conditions, and mental health issues are among the most common disabilities in the United States.

What qualifies for short-term disability in Georgia?

In Georgia, qualifying conditions for short-term disability generally include illnesses or injuries preventing you from performing your job duties, with specifics dependent on your insurance policy.

Useful Links

For further detailed information regarding disability benefits, support services, and application processes, the following resources can prove invaluable:


Receiving a denial for your short-term disability claim can be disheartening. Still, it doesn’t have to be the final word. Understanding why denials happen and what steps you can take to rectify the situation can increase your chances of a successful claim. Remember, tenacity and attention to detail can be your most powerful allies. After all, the purpose of short-term disability insurance is to provide genuine support when it’s needed most. Don’t be discouraged. You’re not alone in this process; with the right knowledge and approach, you can effectively advocate for the coverage you deserve.

Comments are closed.